300B's for the BeePre
- Thread starter johnsonad
- Start date
These tubes draw 1.4 to 1.5 amps and my question is, well the BeePre have any problem in meeting 5v/4% tolerance/1.4 amp on the heater?Paul Joppa
Moderator
Yes, the BeePre will have a severe problem with non-standard current draw. At 1.5 amps, the 300B will see only 4.4 volts, well below what is required for the full 60mA current draw. I doubt Jac would honor a warranty under such conditions, and he would be completely correct in my opinion.
Of course the circuit can be modified, but it would require more current from the filament power supply, causing it to run hotter and thus be in danger of overheating.
The BeePre is not designed to accommodate non-standard "300B" types which do not meet the specification for 300Bs.
The only non-standard tube that will work correctly is the 6A3, or a 6B4 with a different socket. That is not so much by design as a fortuitous accident!
Of course the circuit can be modified, but it would require more current from the filament power supply, causing it to run hotter and thus be in danger of overheating.
The BeePre is not designed to accommodate non-standard "300B" types which do not meet the specification for 300Bs.
The only non-standard tube that will work correctly is the 6A3, or a 6B4 with a different socket. That is not so much by design as a fortuitous accident!
johnsonad said:
You can change a couple resistors, then put the BeePre in a small refrigerator.
Too bad as the EML tubes sound amazing.........
braubeat said:
You could, but then you'd have a preamp with a lot of hum. A big part of the research for the Bee Pre was how to get the circuit as quiet as possible (remember, there is no 3k:8 step-down transformer). AC was out of the question, DC was pretty noisy, then quieter with a regulator, then quieter yet with some active noise cancellation, and finally acceptable with one more filter at the output. Bumping up the current flowing through all this circuitry will increase the heat generated, and the voltage dropped. The current is actually available from the transformer winding itself, but everything else is optimized for the 1.25A filaments, and there is no space for additional heatsinking (literally, the heatsinks in question are flush with the bottom of the wood base, one has to use the rubber feet for proper operation).
-PB
Paul Joppa
Moderator
PB's summary is pretty accurate. That said, I hope we will continue to explore filament power schemes. I feel that further research will pay off.
Now don't start asking "when?!?!?" - this will be a long term project. I think if this preamp is successful, there will be a revision in maybe 5 years. That's roughly the schedule for Foreplay - a new version every 5 years or so.
Now don't start asking "when?!?!?" - this will be a long term project. I think if this preamp is successful, there will be a revision in maybe 5 years. That's roughly the schedule for Foreplay - a new version every 5 years or so.
islanddave
New member
Hello,
What brand of tubes are used in the compete kit? If I order I am debating which el 84 and 300 B tubes to use? But $176 for two 300B's seems very reasonable! By the way earlier here it was mentioned that "non-standard" 300B tubes won't be supported with this amp. What parameters dictate a "standard" 300B?
Thanks Dave
What brand of tubes are used in the compete kit? If I order I am debating which el 84 and 300 B tubes to use? But $176 for two 300B's seems very reasonable! By the way earlier here it was mentioned that "non-standard" 300B tubes won't be supported with this amp. What parameters dictate a "standard" 300B?
Thanks Dave
Paul Joppa
Moderator
Standard in this case means the filament draws 1.2 amps at 5.0 volts. Some "super" 300Bs draw more current.
islanddave
New member
What brand of tubes are used in the compete kit? ;D
All BeePres will ship with Russian Military EL84's (I think they are early 80's), and those who ordered the kit with 300B's will receive EH 300B's.
-PB
-PB
caffeinator
New member
Cool...really looking forward to this kit.
I'm going to finally break out the TJ Meshplate 300B's I got way back when with my Parabees...having aged them to perfection in a box in the basement all these years.
I presume that being used in the shunt reg, rolling different EL84's will have relatively little or no effect on sound - is that a valid presumption?
I'm going to finally break out the TJ Meshplate 300B's I got way back when with my Parabees...having aged them to perfection in a box in the basement all these years.
I presume that being used in the shunt reg, rolling different EL84's will have relatively little or no effect on sound - is that a valid presumption?
Eh, the EL84's are in one of those positions that "shouldn't" matter, but ultimately everything at this level matters at varying levels of importance.
Yeah, it shouldn't matter. But I have changed shunt reg tubes and heard a difference. I don't have any definitive advice on what tube to use. The Russian tubes we supply sound pretty great in a Tode amp. I ended up liking one better than an old Mullard EL84 in that app. Whether that data point applies to the BeePre I can't say.
OK so it's recommended to use ST shaped over Globe to help reduce noise^, vibration and micro-phonic issues^^, something i've read to be inherent with DHT 300b based preamps^.
Any idea if the new Psvane marketing claim, "Due to the use of TEFLON as its base material, the Psvane Mark 2 becomes more stable and durable.", makes a positive difference with aforementioned concerns then other 300B's, or would that be more a function of the bee kits O rings/tube socket then tube type?
^ http://www.zenn.com.sg/DHT%20preamps.htm
"The reason for the scarcity of such designs is the problem of noise which is difficult to overcome in using a direct heated triode as a preamp stage."
^^
http://www.theabsolutesound.com/articles/audio-space-reference-2-linestage-preamplifier/ "To further isolate the tubes from vibration-induced microphonics, the 300Bs are seated in what Audio Space calls
Any idea if the new Psvane marketing claim, "Due to the use of TEFLON as its base material, the Psvane Mark 2 becomes more stable and durable.", makes a positive difference with aforementioned concerns then other 300B's, or would that be more a function of the bee kits O rings/tube socket then tube type?
^ http://www.zenn.com.sg/DHT%20preamps.htm
"The reason for the scarcity of such designs is the problem of noise which is difficult to overcome in using a direct heated triode as a preamp stage."
^^
http://www.theabsolutesound.com/articles/audio-space-reference-2-linestage-preamplifier/ "To further isolate the tubes from vibration-induced microphonics, the 300Bs are seated in what Audio Space calls
I think he is primarily concerned with filament supply noise. Aside from the rather vague info on that page that preamp seems a bit scarce itself. Is there another page somewhere with more info? Couldn't find anything on the zenn web site. I do like the guy's article about damping small signal tubes in oil. Buddha and I talked about doing that years ago, but never followed through with the idea.
BTW I acquired some rubber isolation mounts to try with tube sockets. But their construction was such that we felt that they would probably not hold up to tubes being pushed into the socket. I suspect the best approach may be isolating the entire preamp via a good equipment rack. I have noticed that my lack rack is transferring vibration from our suspended listening room floor if I stomp around. Might be time for the old inner tube trick.
Similar threads
